Arema FC lose 4 points in two consecutive matches: What is happening?
Arema FC vừa đánh rơi 4 điểm trong hai trận hòa liên tiếp tại BRI Super League 2026/2027: bị PSM Makassar cầm hòa 3-3 và bị Persik Kediri cầm hòa 1-1. Nguyên nhân không nằm ở hàng công, mà nằm ở khả năng tập trung tại các ranh giới trận đấu. Sự kiện chính: - Arema FC hòa PSM Makassar 3-3 sau khi bị gỡ bàn ở phút cuối. - Ở derby Đông Java, Arema FC bị Persik Kediri cầm hòa 1-1 sau khi thủng lưới sớm. - Tân binh Careca ghi 2 bàn sau 3 trận, với 6 cú sút và 2 cú trúng đích. - Arema FC hoàn tất 11 cầu thủ ngoại, gồm tiền đạo trẻ người Nigeria. - Nguồn: Bola.net, mùa giải 2026/2027. Hỏi đáp liên quan: - Hỏi: Vì sao Arema FC không thể bảo toàn lợi thế? Đáp: Đội bóng thủng lưới ở phút cuối trước PSM Makassar và ở đầu hiệp một trước Persik Kediri, cho thấy sự tập trung không ổn định ở hai ranh giới thời gian. - Hỏi: Careca đang chơi ra sao? Đáp: Anh là điểm sáng tấn công với 2 bàn sau 3 trận, nhưng tỷ lệ trúng đích 33% cho thấy hiệu quả dứt điểm vẫn cần cải thiện. - Hỏi: Arema FC có đang khủng hoảng? Đáp: Mới chỉ 3 vòng đấu, chưa thể kết luận; cần theo dõi thêm 3 đến 4 vòng tới để xác định xu hướng.
Two matches, four points, the same painful script. Arema FC led, controlled the game, did everything needed to win, then collapsed at the very moments when the match shifted states. Against PSM Makassar in the latest round, Singo Edan drew 3-3 after conceding a late equalizer. Against Persik Kediri at Kanjuruhan, they could only manage a 1-1 draw after conceding early in the first half. Four points have slipped out of their hands in just two matches.
I reviewed both matches as a sports documentary maker. A sports documentary does not shoot the match; it shoots the silence between matches. Arema FC's silence right now sits at two boundaries of the match clock: the final minutes against PSM and the opening minutes against Persik. Shift their focus five minutes forward or five minutes backward, and the story could have been different.
The problem is not scoring. Arema still have individuals capable of making a difference, especially Raianderson da Costa Morais, also known as Careca. The Brazilian attacking player, a new signing from Malaysia's Terengganu FC, has scored two goals in the first three matches. That number makes him the rare bright spot in a squad still trying to gel.
The context needs to be placed next to a transfer milestone: Arema FC completed a squad of 11 foreign players before the season, including a young Nigerian striker. This is a quota-based recruitment pattern, common among Southeast Asian clubs that want to upgrade their squad without the budget for blockbuster signings. The issue is that 11 new people from different football backgrounds have not had time to understand each other on the pitch.
Moreover, the match against Persik Kediri was no ordinary game. It was the East Java Derby, a match carrying the full history, pride and pressure of two big regional clubs. Arema even urged Persik supporters not to come to Kanjuruhan, a rare access-restriction measure that reflects how sensitive the security situation was. When a match is framed by security measures, the players' mentality on the pitch tightens as well.
Arema are following a high-volume foreign signing model, similar to many clubs in Malaysia, Thailand and Vietnam. This approach gives the squad depth, but in exchange it brings instability in the early phase. Foreign players need time to adapt to the climate, pitches, referees and the style of their team-mates. Eleven players arriving at once is a major integration challenge.
Unlike wealthy European clubs that can spend on established stars, Southeast Asian clubs must accept the risk of signing players from regional or African markets. Careca is an example: he came from the Malaysian league, a less competitive competition. His immediate goals are a good sign, but they say nothing yet about durability. A long season tests both mental depth and physical strength.
For Arema specifically, the risk lies in relying on one new signing for creativity in the final third. If Careca gets injured or loses form, who will take responsibility? That is the question the board needs to answer before the mid-season transfer window opens. Big Indonesian clubs usually do not bet their entire strategy on one individual.
Careca himself admitted that the team could have made better use of the chances created, and that the goals conceded came from unpredictable bounces rather than a planned tactical scheme from the opponent. But from an analytical perspective, the luck story does not hold. The late goal conceded against PSM and the early goal conceded against Persik are not two separate incidents. They sit at opposite ends of the match clock, and their appearance in consecutive matches is a systemic signal.
If unlucky bounces were truly random, they would spread evenly across 90 minutes. A team conceding in the final minute of one match and in the opening minute of the next shows that the collective focus tends to become unstable at time boundaries. This is no longer a story about a centre-back making a mistake or a goalkeeper failing to save; it is a story about how the whole team operates when the match moves into transitional moments.
The core issue for Arema FC is game-state management, not defensive quality. Arema scored three goals against PSM Makassar, meaning the attack can create a large volume of chances. But they could not keep their breathing rhythm when the opponent pushed late on. In the derby, they were not ready from the opening whistle. This is an organisational problem, not a problem of any single position. A defence is only truly strong when the whole team knows how to read moments and slow the match down when necessary.
Four points in the early season can decide a club's final position. In a long league, champions win the title by turning draws into wins. PSM Makassar are a direct rival in the upper-mid band. Letting them equalise in the final minute costs not just two points, but also the head-to-head advantage. The East Java Derby carries emotional value far beyond three points. Drawing against Persik makes supporters feel the team is not ready for the big occasions.
Indonesian football is famous for its fiery atmosphere. Kanjuruhan is one of the most difficult stadiums to play in. But when the home team has to ask away supporters not to attend, it is a sign that the heat has gone beyond sport. Match security becomes part of the tactics, and the players face extra pressure from playing in a tightly controlled environment. The history of East Java derbies includes riots and sanctions. Arema's decision to limit the crowd is a way to protect the club from disciplinary risk. But it also reduces the home advantage, because the stadium lacks the full noise needed to pressure the opponent.
Careca is a real bright spot, but also a bottleneck. Six shots in three matches, two on target, two goals. He is the type of player who shoots often and takes responsibility in the final third, not a low-touch playmaker. That creates a clear dependency. Having followed Indonesian football for years, I have noticed that title-contending teams usually have at least three different scoring sources. Arema are currently putting too much expectation on one newcomer.
The stat of two goals in three matches needs to be read alongside the shot count: six shots, two on target. That means Careca's on-target rate is around 33%, not high compared with attacking midfielders in leading Asian leagues. He accepts taking many shots, which helps his presence, but it also means more misses. The key question is where those shots come from. If they come from clear counter-attacks, that is a positive sign. If they come from long-range efforts, the efficiency will soon drop. So do not rush to crown Careca the saviour after only three matches.
Careca also admitted that his physical and mental preparation has been drained by high-intensity games. The congested early-season schedule, including President's Cup fixtures, creates accumulated pressure. When fitness drops, concentration in stoppage time is the first thing to disappear. I have seen many teams lose points for the same reason: they were not tired from running too much, but tired from concentrating non-stop.
Based on my experience following matches, I have realised that football in Southeast Asia increasingly values tactical flexibility over pure physical strength. Arema have good individuals, but they have not formed a clear identity without the ball. Successful teams in the Indonesian league usually press immediately after losing possession. They do not give the opponent time to breathe. Arema allowed PSM to push forward at the end, and allowed Persik to build comfortably from the back in the first half. That is not because they are weak, but because they do not yet know how to control their own tempo.
The contrarian view here is this: Arema do not need a new centre-back or a world-class goalkeeper. If you only look at the four dropped points, you might quickly conclude that the defence is broken and needs reinforcements. But the available data does not support that conclusion. The goals conceded came from collective lapses, from pressing that was pushed too deep to risky passes in their own half. The problem is in the process, not in the people.

Careca himself said the opponent did not really have chances to threaten Arema's defence. If that assessment is accurate, Arema are losing points from low-probability situations for the opponent. But football does not reward the team that controls better. Football rewards the team that avoids mistakes at the moments with the biggest consequences. Kazan taught me one thing: some mistakes deserve to be pronounced for a lifetime. Arema are in the process of pronouncing them again, and the question is whether they can correct the tone.
If we look back at the history of Indonesian football, many teams have started slowly and still finished high. Arema have gone through similar phases before. The important thing is not to lose faith in the process. Teams with a strong identity usually overcome early-season shocks by returning to the basics: defensive organisation, distances between lines, and the ability to read situations. Arema fans have reasons to worry, but they have also witnessed spectacular comebacks. Football never moves in a straight line. A win in the next round can erase all criticism. Conversely, another defeat could push the club into a spiral of pressure.
It must be said clearly: this is only the start of the season, and three matches is too small a sample to conclude a crisis. What I want to follow is not whether Careca scores more, but whether Arema repeat the pattern of conceding at match boundaries in the next three rounds. If it happens for a third time, that is no longer luck; that is a signal for the coaching staff to redesign reaction drills for the whole team at the most sensitive moments.

Indonesian football once taught me that a team's speed of disappearance does not come from a long-range shot or a set piece, but from the seconds when the whole team thinks the match is under control. Arema still have the chance to rewrite the story. The biggest question is not how many foreign players they have, but whether they have the courage to look straight into the silence between matches – where my documentary always finds the truth. The answer will come as soon as the next round.
